sand vs no sand pros and cons

meazy · 04/30/2011, 08:15 AM

hi guys i am new been running my 125 gal for a year now i have crused coral and i keep having problems with cyano and this gray black stuff when i siphen and the sand is not white like it was when i first but it their
so the question is sand or no sand???? i would like your thought of this the pros the cons thx guys

peppie · 04/30/2011, 10:53 AM

If you search Barebottom on this site you will get alot of information on barebottom. There is a thread (Barebottom club)

benzreef · 04/30/2011, 11:12 AM

I have had shallow sand beds in all of my tanks until a few years ago with my current tank. I loved the natural look of the sand, but I am more in love with the lower nutrient levels of a barebottom setup. The bottom glass will be covered in coralline algae in no time. I do miss the look of the sand though. I always get comments like "where's the sand?" then I always have to explain why there is none. All in all, I will be sticking with the barebottom setup with all of my future tanks. Every setup is different though. Have you tried stepping up the current flowing to bottom of the tank? That may agitate it just enough to be aesthetic.

duncantse · 04/30/2011, 11:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by meazy

hi guys i am new been running my 125 gal for a year now i have crused coral and i keep having problems with cyano and this gray black stuff when i siphen and the sand is not white like it was when i first but it their
so the question is sand or no sand???? i would like your thought of this the pros the cons thx guys

Hmmm, you mentioned the red stuff and black stuff. This is probably cyano. I myself have crushed coral too and I have also experienced red and black cyano. This is how I got rid of it:

1.Reduce feeding (Once a day would be fine)
2.Reduce lights (I leave mine on for 6 hours including actinics)
3.During water change, siphone all the cyano out.

Once all the cyano cleared up, the sandbed looked very nice.

meazy · 04/30/2011, 04:35 PM

thx for all the help i will check out the post for bb tanks

Lamball1 · 04/30/2011, 05:24 PM

whatever would happen, i'd always go for a sandbed.
I like a realistc look to my tank.

04/30/2011, 08:15 AM	#1
meazy Registered Member Join Date: Apr 2011 Posts: 3	sand vs no sand pros and cons hi guys i am new been running my 125 gal for a year now i have crused coral and i keep having problems with cyano and this gray black stuff when i siphen and the sand is not white like it was when i first but it their so the question is sand or no sand???? i would like your thought of this the pros the cons thx guys

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Pros and Cons of deep bed sand and live rock	kettlecorn	New to the Hobby	9	04/27/2010 05:11 PM
shallow sand bed - pros & cons	cmbspd	New to the Hobby	6	01/21/2010 04:45 PM
Sand Beds... How deep and what are the pros and cons	lowendmelody	Reef Discussion	16	10/31/2008 09:06 AM
Black Sand pros & cons	ron burgandy	Reef Discussion	17	05/13/2006 02:55 PM

04/30/2011, 10:53 AM	#2
peppie Registered Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 1,883	If you search Barebottom on this site you will get alot of information on barebottom. There is a thread (Barebottom club)

04/30/2011, 11:12 AM	#3
benzreef Registered Member Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: The tip of Lake Superior Posts: 256	I have had shallow sand beds in all of my tanks until a few years ago with my current tank. I loved the natural look of the sand, but I am more in love with the lower nutrient levels of a barebottom setup. The bottom glass will be covered in coralline algae in no time. I do miss the look of the sand though. I always get comments like "where's the sand?" then I always have to explain why there is none. All in all, I will be sticking with the barebottom setup with all of my future tanks. Every setup is different though. Have you tried stepping up the current flowing to bottom of the tank? That may agitate it just enough to be aesthetic.

04/30/2011, 04:35 PM	#5
meazy Registered Member Join Date: Apr 2011 Posts: 3	thx for all the help i will check out the post for bb tanks

04/30/2011, 05:24 PM	#6
Lamball1 Registered Member Join Date: Nov 2010 Posts: 203	whatever would happen, i'd always go for a sandbed. I like a realistc look to my tank.