Powder Blue dead

Mike Murphy · 10/14/2008, 02:36 PM

9 days after bringing it home my 6 inch powder blue died suddenly. Water parameters in my 125 were excellent.
PH 8.4
Alk 2.5
Calcium 400
Amonia 0
Nitrite 0
Nitrate 0
Salinity 1.026
Temp 78 F

Tank has been running about 60 days with 6 inch dsb and 180lbs of live rock & fuge, skimmer, calcium reactor etc.

Have a yellow tank , small blue pacific tang and maroon clown, soft corals & banded coral shrimp. All of which are doing well. It had been eating fine, looked a little pale in the begining but seemed to perk up. Second of 2 fish that I have purchased from that store that have died within days. The first one was a small Copperband that had been eating pods but died within 4 -5 days.

Begining to think that maybe the collection source is not good for this store. Powder Blue was fairly large. Wonder if it was caught with chemicals?

All specimens were introduced at 1-2 week intervals and no spikes.
Comments?

Beach Magnolia · 10/14/2008, 02:45 PM

I sure do feel your pain. I had a similar thing happen, although mine lived a little bit longer than yours. It wasn't until I went to a local club meeting and explained the symptoms that it was brought to my attention it was probably a chemically caught fish.

I don't frequent that LFS anymore.

Beach Magnolia · 10/14/2008, 02:47 PM

One other thing - you may want to give your tank a longer break-in period before adding some of the fussier fishies.

Mike Murphy · 10/14/2008, 03:04 PM

Normally I would go a little longer on the break-in but I seeded this tank early on and it has had an abundant supply or algae that I harvest from the over flow grids for the tangs which they readily wolf down. I have kept Powder Blues before in fish only without live rock and kept them for several years in worse conditions 20 -30 years back without a death. Think I'm going to change stores. A fellow reefer suggested a place called The Abyss on the north side of Indy. Think I'll check then out.

10/14/2008, 02:36 PM	#1
Mike Murphy Registered Member Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: Greencastle, Indiana Posts: 258	Powder Blue dead 9 days after bringing it home my 6 inch powder blue died suddenly. Water parameters in my 125 were excellent. PH 8.4 Alk 2.5 Calcium 400 Amonia 0 Nitrite 0 Nitrate 0 Salinity 1.026 Temp 78 F Tank has been running about 60 days with 6 inch dsb and 180lbs of live rock & fuge, skimmer, calcium reactor etc. Have a yellow tank , small blue pacific tang and maroon clown, soft corals & banded coral shrimp. All of which are doing well. It had been eating fine, looked a little pale in the begining but seemed to perk up. Second of 2 fish that I have purchased from that store that have died within days. The first one was a small Copperband that had been eating pods but died within 4 -5 days. Begining to think that maybe the collection source is not good for this store. Powder Blue was fairly large. Wonder if it was caught with chemicals? All specimens were introduced at 1-2 week intervals and no spikes. Comments?

10/14/2008, 02:45 PM	#2
Beach Magnolia Registered Member Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: New Tampa Posts: 124	I sure do feel your pain. I had a similar thing happen, although mine lived a little bit longer than yours. It wasn't until I went to a local club meeting and explained the symptoms that it was brought to my attention it was probably a chemically caught fish. I don't frequent that LFS anymore. __________________ Annette Current Tank Info: 45 gal mixed reef

10/14/2008, 02:47 PM	#3
Beach Magnolia Registered Member Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: New Tampa Posts: 124	One other thing - you may want to give your tank a longer break-in period before adding some of the fussier fishies. __________________ Annette Current Tank Info: 45 gal mixed reef

10/14/2008, 03:04 PM	#4
Mike Murphy Registered Member Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: Greencastle, Indiana Posts: 258	Normally I would go a little longer on the break-in but I seeded this tank early on and it has had an abundant supply or algae that I harvest from the over flow grids for the tangs which they readily wolf down. I have kept Powder Blues before in fish only without live rock and kept them for several years in worse conditions 20 -30 years back without a death. Think I'm going to change stores. A fellow reefer suggested a place called The Abyss on the north side of Indy. Think I'll check then out.