FOWLR 55 gallon canister recommendations

[lilouisianagal]

I have a 55 gallon FOWLR that I would like a quieter filter for from our current Aqueon hang on back filters. Any recommendations for a decent quality low to moderate cost canister filter? Thanks!

[Xavibear]

I wouldn't add a canister. Your filtration should be happening with your rock & sand. A skimmer would be a much better investment in my opinion.

[Fabien]

I have a Marineland C360 for my 55 gallon (Fish only) for about a year now. Very quiet, the rotor broke when I received it and it was very difficult to get the support to answer my emails. Since then, I had no issue with it.

[mnkykng77]

I'd suggest getting an Eheim canister filter. They are quiet and are really good quality.

[Pomacanthus1]

If you already have a good skimmer and are just looking for a supplemental biofilter, definitely Eheim.

[Sapelo]

In my opinion and experience, canister filters do not belong with reef tanks. Unless you are committed (really committed) to checking and cleaning them, it's way too easy to have a hidden problem. Leave canisters to freshwater tanks.

[lilouisianagal]

So would I be better off getting a protein skimmer (recommendations?) and something to move the water (is that called a power head?)?

[Pomacanthus1]

Originally Posted by lilouisianagal

So would I be better off getting a protein skimmer (recommendations?) and something to move the water (is that called a power head?)?

If you have at least one pound of established live rock per gallon then you will have enough rock for a functional biofilter that will take care of ammonia/nitrites, etc. If that's the case, the canister is unneeded, and you're better off putting the money towards a good skimmer. What's your budget? Good skimmers start at around $300, but you can also find good ones that are used and save a good bit that way. Also, do you have a sump? If not, you will need a hang-on version of a skimmer which will limit your options.

Powerheads are small pumps that are used to create currents in the aquarium, which the fish and corals need. Since you're not keeping corals all you really need to worry about is having enough current to keep the water well circulated in the tank and prevent detritus buildup. Good surface agitation is also important, so you'd want at least one powerhead pointing at the surface. I've been out of the hobby for a few years and I'm not really familiar with the powerheads I see people using these days, so someone else will have to recommend a brand.

[Xavibear]

Aquamaxx & Reef Octopus make good hob skimmers. They start around $200. Definitely a much better investment than a canister imo.