PLEASE check out your intended fish purchases here first!

[wcharon]

Originally Posted by snorvich

I love Carberryi anthias but anthias do best with multiple feedings per day because their metabolism and energy level is high. Long term, once per day will not properly sustain them.

Ok... If i get the Anthias i will also buy an automatic feeder. Love small fishes . That way ithe tank don't seem to crowded...

Thanks once again...

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by wcharon

Ok... If i get the Anthias i will also buy an automatic feeder. Love small fishes . That way ithe tank don't seem to crowded...

Thanks once again...

Automatic feeders do well with pellets. However, many anthias will not eat pellets.

[wcharon]

Originally Posted by snorvich

Automatic feeders do well with pellets. However, many anthias will not eat pellets.

Ok.. I will make arrangements becuse saw pics of the Carberryi and they are awesome...

Appreciated....

[SpartaReef]

Thx anyway

[cjbtech]

Originally Posted by snorvich

Sorry, I do not provide compatibility analysis on aggressive fish tanks. A lionfish makes a great centerpiece fish. But only with no tank mates.

I understand your position on aggressive fish. my 1st concern was to make sure the Lion would be at home in a tank of that size. From what I have read I believe so. I just think they are beautiful. Do you see this as a poor choice for a beginner if it were alone?

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by cjbtech

I understand your position on aggressive fish. my 1st concern was to make sure the Lion would be at home in a tank of that size. From what I have read I believe so. I just think they are beautiful. Do you see this as a poor choice for a beginner if it were alone?

No. Lionfish as the only fish in a reef tank are no problem whatsoever as they are totally coral safe. Although they do not do much except hover waiting for the next meal, they are very pretty to look at.

[cjbtech]

Thanks for your help. Some of my favorite fish have been rock or shell dwelling Cichlids, so I don't need a floor show to be entertained. Thanks Mike

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by cjbtech

Thanks for your help. Some of my favorite fish have been rock or shell dwelling Cichlids, so I don't need a floor show to be entertained. Thanks Mike

Actually, their behavior in a reef tank can be mesmerizing. I have spent countless hours night diving with lionfish (Papua New Guinea). There is nothing quite like two 15 inch wingspan lionfish, one just off each shoulder accompanying me on a night dive and snapping up any fish that I happen to light up with my dive light.

[greg1786]

125 gallon tank (72"x18")
Current fish:
Barred dartfish
Target mandarin
Pair cinnamon clowns
Daimond goby
Lavender tang
Yellow tang
Will be adding 75lbs of liverock and rearranging the aquascape so figured, if possible, it would be my only chance, or best chance to add another tang to an already established tank with two other tangs. Want to add ONE of the following: atlantic blue tang or gold rim ( powder grey) tang. Not sure 125 gallons is adequate for three tangs to be happy and healthy? If so would either work out or would one be a safer bet than the other? Thanks -Greg

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by greg1786

125 gallon tank (72"x18")
Current fish:
Barred dartfish
Target mandarin
Pair cinnamon clowns
Daimond goby
Lavender tang
Yellow tang
Will be adding 75lbs of liverock and rearranging the aquascape so figured, if possible, it would be my only chance, or best chance to add another tang to an already established tank with two other tangs. Want to add ONE of the following: atlantic blue tang or gold rim ( powder grey) tang. Not sure 125 gallons is adequate for three tangs to be happy and healthy? If so would either work out or would one be a safer bet than the other? Thanks -Greg

I would definitely not add another tang. Tank is not really large enough and an established yellow tang will not allow it.

[dirt1008]

I have a 55 gallon with about a 3" deep sand bed, and 60 lbs of LR, I have a 20L sump with a Reef Octopus NWB110 and a 13 gallon fuge. For lights I have two Reefbreaders LED fixtures. My tank has cycled and my list of fish I'd like to get goes as follows: 2 Clowns, 1 Yellow Eye Kole Tang?, and 1 Green Mandarin. What do you think? I know the Tang thing scares everyone when I have a 55, but I've heard success stories. Also, what kind of clean up crew would you suggest? I plan on keeping corals also. Any help is greatly appreciated.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by dirt1008

I have a 55 gallon with about a 3" deep sand bed, and 60 lbs of LR, I have a 20L sump with a Reef Octopus NWB110 and a 13 gallon fuge. For lights I have two Reefbreaders LED fixtures. My tank has cycled and my list of fish I'd like to get goes as follows: 2 Clowns, 1 Yellow Eye Kole Tang?, and 1 Green Mandarin. What do you think? I know the Tang thing scares everyone when I have a 55, but I've heard success stories. Also, what kind of clean up crew would you suggest? I plan on keeping corals also. Any help is greatly appreciated.

Reef Central's recommended tank size for this tang is 75 gallons. A mandarin is marginal in a 55 gallon tank for long term success. If you add a producing refugium to this tank, the mandarin becomes more realistic.

[dirt1008]

Are there any small tangs suitable for a 55?

[reefermax]

75G Tank 48x18x21
Sump w/ SWC Xtreme 120; BRS Biopellet, GFO, and Carbon reactors.
~80 lbs. Marco Dry rock, 60 lbs. Bahama Aragonite from Marco rock.

Proposed Stocking:
Chevron Tang
Foxface Rabbitfish
Male Blue Throat Triggerfish
Leopard Wrasse
Orangespot Diamond Goby

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by dirt1008

Are there any small tangs suitable for a 55?

Reef Central's recommendation on tank size for tangs can be found here.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by reefermax

75G Tank 48x18x21
Sump w/ SWC Xtreme 120; BRS Biopellet, GFO, and Carbon reactors.
~80 lbs. Marco Dry rock, 60 lbs. Bahama Aragonite from Marco rock.

Proposed Stocking:
Chevron Tang Reef Central's tank size recommendation for tangs can be found here.
Foxface Rabbitfish requires a larger tank
Male Blue Throat Triggerfish needs a much larger tank
Leopard Wrasse expert level fish requiring an established tank, sand, and peaceful tank mates
Orangespot Diamond Goby

[gsiegel]

Hey Steve. I just wanted to post an updated stocking list for your thoughts for a 280g FOWLR
currently in the tank:
-3 blue/green chromis (I know may be down to 1 eventually but all good and as my first fish in the tank have been doing great ever since)
-mated pair of black/white oscellarus
-gold headed sleeper goby
-magnificent fox face
-blond naso
-mimic tang
-flame angel
-xmas wrasse
-exquisite wrasse
-labout's wrasse (seeing some aggression issues w/him)
-lineatus wrasse

planned possible additions in order I am thinking - ok w/this mix:
-possibly other wrasses I am considering (of course not all):
- orange-back fairy
- pink margin fairy
- carpenter
- radiant
- mccosker's
- linespot flasher wrasse

-mated pair of bellus angels (or wattanaba)
-pair of blue jaw triggers
-aussie harlequin tusk
-toby puffer (asking for trouble - prone to nip?)
-blue face or $cribbled angel

Thanks Steve! Diving with the lions seems really cool!

[SpartaReef]

I was thinking of having the following in my 120g mixed reef tank. It has a sump and will keep a refugium inside it... Nothing is setup yet. I apologize for lacking additional info... would need to know best conditions for this list and will do my best to make accommodation...

Also what would be the ideal sequence of introducing these fish?

-Chromis (~7?)

-Clown fish (a pair of Clarkii)

-Dragon wrasse (gotta double check... How much damage can they actually do?)

-Fire shrimp

-starfish (3 or 4 maybe? each a different kind)

-urchin (just 1 would be cool)

-Fu Manchu Lion fish (probably last to introduce?)(at this point not likely or would be the only type of fish, maybe multiple lions?)

-cleaning crew (probably will stay away from hermits though, Fu will just eat them)

-feather dusters, anemones and various corals...

I want a lot of diversity and am willing to take a long time and deal with the requirements.



Well I'm a long ways off from getting any of these yet... And I realize you don't advise on predator fish, so just pretend I don't have the Fu on there... I will keep that point of view in mind... it's likely that I won't get one, or will only get lion fish... depending.

Thanks for your input!

[moonyrat]

30gal long 3 yrs old tank
current list:
2x false clown
1 tailspot blenny
1 ywg
1 cleaner shrimp
many snails and hermits

can I add a bi-color blenny?

[shellynjason]

Hi there , I have a 120 60x18x26 with a 'new' mixed reef (all small frags). About an inch or more sand bed and plenty of rock hiding places.

Present fsh - two blk/wht small clowns and one small blue chromis. My bioload is very load (no nitrates) so I know I need a few more fish to help feed the sps.

Our wish list:

Magnificent Foxface
Chevron Tang (or Kole)
perl jawfish

and possibly two small dark blue or red fish (any suggestions)

Also, which should be added first,second,ect. I don't want to load the tank all at once and mess the balance up. Thanks!

[reefermax]

Ok Round 2:
75G Tank 48x18x21
40G Sump w/ SWC Xtreme 120; BRS Biopellet, GFO, and Carbon reactors.
~80 lbs. Marco Dry rock, 60 lbs. Bahama Aragonite from Marco rock.

Proposed Stocking:
Percula Clown x2
Blue Chromis x4
Mckosker's Wrasse
Flame Angel
Orangespot Diamond Goby
Tailspot Blenny

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by gsiegel

Hey Steve. I just wanted to post an updated stocking list for your thoughts for a 280g FOWLR
currently in the tank:
-3 blue/green chromis (I know may be down to 1 eventually but all good and as my first fish in the tank have been doing great ever since)
-mated pair of black/white oscellarus
-gold headed sleeper goby may be ok, may starve
-magnificent fox face
-blond naso
-mimic tang
-flame angel
-xmas wrasse
-exquisite wrasse
-labout's wrasse (seeing some aggression issues w/him) yes, they can be to other conspecifics
-lineatus wrasse

planned possible additions in order I am thinking - ok w/this mix:
-possibly other wrasses I am considering (of course not all):
- orange-back fairy
- pink margin fairy males ship poorly
- carpenter
- radiant
- mccosker's
- linespot flasher wrasse

wrasses require a tightly covered tank

-mated pair of bellus angels (or wattanaba) males ship poorly, finding healthy males is not easy
-pair of blue jaw triggers
-aussie harlequin tusk may eat small fish
-toby puffer (asking for trouble - prone to nip?) will nip
-blue face or $cribbled angel

you are starting to have a lot of largish fish; that will make your tank look small

Thanks Steve! Diving with the lions seems really cool!

Yeah, it was. I dove with those lions for about 5 years running. They were great about staying on my "wings".

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by reefermax

Ok Round 2:
75G Tank 48x18x21
40G Sump w/ SWC Xtreme 120; BRS Biopellet, GFO, and Carbon reactors.
~80 lbs. Marco Dry rock, 60 lbs. Bahama Aragonite from Marco rock.

Proposed Stocking:
Percula Clown x2
Blue Chromis x4 will likely winnow down to just one
Mckosker's Wrasse needs a tightly covered tank (not egg crate)
Flame Angel
Orangespot Diamond Goby
Tailspot Blenny

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by SpartaReef

I was thinking of having the following in my 120g mixed reef tank. It has a sump and will keep a refugium inside it... Nothing is setup yet. I apologize for lacking additional info... would need to know best conditions for this list and will do my best to make accommodation...

Also what would be the ideal sequence of introducing these fish?

-Chromis (~7?) will likely become one

-Clown fish (a pair of Clarkii) aggressive

-Dragon wrasse (gotta double check... How much damage can they actually do?) aggressive; do you really want a one foot fish

-Fire shrimp

-starfish (3 or 4 maybe? each a different kind)

-urchin (just 1 would be cool)

-Fu Manchu Lion fish (probably last to introduce?)(at this point not likely or would be the only type of fish, maybe multiple lions?) will eat fish and shrimp

-cleaning crew (probably will stay away from hermits though, Fu will just eat them)

-feather dusters, anemones and various corals...

I want a lot of diversity and am willing to take a long time and deal with the requirements.



Well I'm a long ways off from getting any of these yet... And I realize you don't advise on predator fish, so just pretend I don't have the Fu on there... I will keep that point of view in mind... it's likely that I won't get one, or will only get lion fish... depending.

Thanks for your input!

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by moonyrat

30gal long 3 yrs old tank
current list:
2x false clown
1 tailspot blenny
1 ywg
1 cleaner shrimp
many snails and hermits

can I add a bi-color blenny?

only one blenny, especially in small tanks