PLEASE check out your intended fish purchases here first!

[HUNTER1]

Originally Posted by snorvich

Should be fine.

Sounds good for my second option, thanks

[wouldukindly]

I have a 50 gallon with some bumble bee snails and a nassarius snail.

revised list of what i would like to get-
2 Kaudern's Cardinal, Tank Bred
1 Royal Gramma Basslet
1 Ocellaris Clownfish, Tank Bred

thanks for any help or fish suggestions!

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by wouldukindly

I have a 50 gallon with some bumble bee snails and a nassarius snail.

revised list of what i would like to get-
2 Kaudern's Cardinal, Tank Bred For two, must be a male plus female
1 Royal Gramma Basslet
1 Ocellaris Clownfish, Tank Bred

thanks for any help or fish suggestions!

Except as noted, this will work

[Matt21345]

well I am going to keep an eye on my sixline over the next day or so. if it gives my new clown problems I will be bringing him to the store and they already said they would take him. if I do I would like to get a royal gramma. would this be a bad mix with the 2 clowns, green clown goby, and firefish.

other possible tank mates would be to replace 6 line if needed, please let me know what you think
- hector goby
- rainford goby
- pearly jaw fish
- mandarin goby
- Red Pygmy Possum Wrasse (I don't know if this is aggressive or not)
- Steinitz Goby
- Aurora Goby
- Zebra Barred Goby
- Diagonal Bar Prawn Goby
- pajama cardinal
- Ruby cardinal

[wouldukindly]

Originally Posted by snorvich

Except as noted, this will work

awesome thanks

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by Matt21345

well I am going to keep an eye on my sixline over the next day or so. if it gives my new clown problems I will be bringing him to the store and they already said they would take him. if I do I would like to get a royal gramma. would this be a bad mix with the 2 clowns, green clown goby, and firefish. should be fine

other possible tank mates would be to replace 6 line if needed, please let me know what you think
- hector goby should be fine
- rainford goby should be fine
- pearly jaw fishshould be fine
- mandarin goby absolutely not
- Red Pygmy Possum Wrasse (I don't know if this is aggressive or not) should be excellent
- Steinitz Goby should be fine
- Aurora Goby should be fine
- Zebra Barred Goby
- Diagonal Bar Prawn Goby
- pajama cardinal
- Ruby cardinal

[pyithar]

hello, i have a 50g tank(3 footer) with a 6g fuge and 15g sump running for 5 months. i have some zoanthids, LPS, and soft corals. and a wildcaught clarkii clown fish's been in my tank for over 2 months already. now i plan to add more fish.
i just bought a lawn mower blenny. does that mean i cannot get another blenny like a bicolor blenny anymore?
i'm looking at a female tricolor wrasse. can i add a male tricolor later when it becomes available? will the female get along with clarkii? i don't really like female color so should i get a six line wrasse instead?are all wrasse pods population reducers?
i plan to have a mandarin in the future. so should i avoid all wrasse?
i also like
a royal gramma
a fire fish
a bangai cardial
since i have 2 fish already, i'll add 3 more. not sure about mandarin in the future.
in which order should i buy?
please advise me. thank you for ur time.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by pyithar

hello, i have a 50g tank(3 footer) with a 6g fuge and 15g sump running for 5 months. i have some zoanthids, LPS, and soft corals. and a wildcaught clarkii clown fish's been in my tank for over 2 months already. now i plan to add more fish.
i just bought a lawn mower blenny. does that mean i cannot get another blenny like a bicolor blenny anymore? That is correct
i'm looking at a female tricolor wrasse. which requires a larger tank; which means that two require an even larger tank can i add a male tricolor later when it becomes available? will the female get along with clarkii? A. are very aggressive and will want to control your entire tank, especially if a juvenile is added

i don't really like female color so should i get a six line wrasse instead?are all wrasse pods population reducers? Pretty much yes, but a six line is also aggressive and will limit tank mates
i plan to have a mandarin in the future. so should i avoid all wrasse? Your tank is not large enough to sustain a mandarin, especially with other copepod eaters
i also like
a royal gramma
a fire fish
a bangai cardial
since i have 2 fish already, i'll add 3 more. not sure about mandarin in the future.
in which order should i buy?
please advise me. thank you for ur time.

Too many variables with "what if" so please provide a stocking list and I will analyze it.

[pyithar]

thanks for the quick reply!

ok my stocking list would be:
one clarkii clown (already have)
one lawn mower blenny (already have)

i'd like to choose three fish out of the following:
one bangai cardinal
one royal gramma
one firefish
one mandarin
one bicolor dottyback
one sixline wrasse
one blue green chromis

please pick 3 fish out of the above 7 for me because i don't know which combination would work. from my readings, i've learned that most marine fish hate their tank mates, and like to live alone. therefore i don't know which ones to pick anymore.

again, thank you!

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by pyithar

thanks for the quick reply!

ok my stocking list would be:
one clarkii clown (already have) will likely be a problem due to aggression
one lawn mower blenny (already have)

i'd like to choose three fish out of the following:
one bangai cardinal tank raised
one royal gramma
one firefish
one mandarin avoid due to tank size
one bicolor dottyback avoid due to aggression
one sixline wrasse avoid due to aggression
one blue green chromis

please pick 3 fish out of the above 7 for me because i don't know which combination would work. from my readings, i've learned that most marine fish hate their tank mates, and like to live alone. therefore i don't know which ones to pick anymore.

again, thank you!

[pyithar]

thanks so much! really appreciate it.

[fscmocsaj]

35G hex front, coralife 2 fixture T5 78w, fluval 206 canister, hydor slim skim 65, 2 hydor 425 powerhead, 48lbs base rock, 5lb live rock, 25lb live sand.

Looking to add longnose hawkfish, coral beauty, engineer goby, sandsifting goby, and that's it for now for fish I still need to do some research but if you have any suggestions. Also I want to add coral but not too sure what to get maybe some zoos and mushrooms to start out.

[fscmocsaj]

oh and a cleaner wrasse

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by fscmocsaj

35G hex front, coralife 2 fixture T5 78w, fluval 206 canister, hydor slim skim 65, 2 hydor 425 powerhead, 48lbs base rock, 5lb live rock, 25lb live sand.

Looking to add
longnose hawkfish not shrimp safe but an excellent fish
coral beauty not coral safe
engineer goby, I do not recommend this fish, especially in this sized tank as get gets to be a foot long and will rearrange your aquascaping
sandsifting goby which species?
cleaner wrasse only the african captured one will survive and it will not work with the fish you have planned in the tank since none of the fish you are planning will allow themselves to be cleaned; also this fish will not eat parasites such as cryptocaryon irritans

and that's it for now for fish I still need to do some research but if you have any suggestions. Also I want to add coral but not too sure what to get maybe some zoos and mushrooms to start out.

[SaltWaterAdam]

I've got a 29g. I have 2 occs and a very very peaceful 6 line. Thinking about a blue axil chromis and an orchid dotty back for the final 2 fish.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by SaltWaterAdam

I've got a 29g. I have 2 occs and a very very peaceful 6 line. Thinking about a blue axil chromis and an orchid dotty back for the final 2 fish.

The six line is not likely to remain peaceful. It is highly likely to take out any pseudochromis even a relatively peaceful one like P. fridmani. The chromis should be fine

[fermentedhiker]

Thinking of setting up a 40B as a low to medium light reef tank to house a Fu Manchu lionfish(wanted something different than the other tank I'm setting up as a mixed medium-high light reef)

For tankmates I was thinking a Matted Filefish and a Flame Hawkfish. Are either of these in serious danger of becoming a meal for the lionfish?

Would maintaining a population of SW acclimated Mollys and/or guppy's improve their chances of being ignored by the lionfish?

Thanks
Adam

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by fermentedhiker

Thinking of setting up a 40B as a low to medium light reef tank to house a Fu Manchu lionfish(wanted something different than the other tank I'm setting up as a mixed medium-high light reef)

For tankmates I was thinking a Matted Filefish and a Flame Hawkfish. Are either of these in serious danger of becoming a meal for the lionfish?

Would maintaining a population of SW acclimated Mollys and/or guppy's improve their chances of being ignored by the lionfish?

Thanks
Adam

I do not provide commentary/analysis on aggressive fish tanks. A lionfish will eat, or in worst case, try to eat, anything it can fit into its mouth. It's mouth is larger than it appears because of how it eats its prey.

[archangel91]

Current setup is a 46 gal bowfront, no corals at the moment, but would like to start introducing some in the future.

Current stock:
2 ocellaris clownfish
1 bangaii cardinal
1 multicolor fairy wrasse

Would like to add (needs some narrowing down):
royal gramma
purple firefish goby
flame or potters angel
green mandarin (finding conflicting info on min. tank size?)
if a mandarin is un-realistic possibly a spotted goby or some other type of bottom dweller/burrower

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by archangel91

Current setup is a 46 gal bowfront, no corals at the moment, but would like to start introducing some in the future.

Current stock:
2 ocellaris clownfish
1 bangaii cardinal
1 multicolor fairy wrasse

Would like to add (needs some narrowing down):
royal gramma fine
purple firefish goby
flame or potters angel flame is fine, potters is more difficult
green mandarin (finding conflicting info on min. tank size?)
if a mandarin is un-realistic possibly a spotted goby or some other type of bottom dweller/burrower

a mandarin is unrealistic in this sized tank for long term success; any of the shrimp goby pairs would work assuming you have sand

[Art13]

I would like a professionals opinion on this if you don't mind. I know it says the minimum tank size for a kole tang is 75 gallons, but my question is this. I was looking into getting a small one to start with, that will first be put into a 60 gallon tank, I also have a 139 gallon tank i will be setting up in about 6 months. Assuming the growth rate on the tang isn't too fast, would he be ok in the smaller tank for about a year or so until the other tank is up and running? The tank is 4 feet long, 21 inches high, 12 inches front to back.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by Art13

I would like a professionals opinion on this if you don't mind. I know it says the minimum tank size for a kole tang is 75 gallons, but my question is this. I was looking into getting a small one to start with, that will first be put into a 60 gallon tank, I also have a 139 gallon tank i will be setting up in about 6 months. Assuming the growth rate on the tang isn't too fast, would he be ok in the smaller tank for about a year or so until the other tank is up and running? The tank is 4 feet long, 21 inches high, 12 inches front to back.

As these are common, easily available fish, Reef Central always feels it is best to wait until you have an appropriately sized tank rather than buying a fish with the expectation that a larger tank will be available. It is not fish size that determines the appropriate tank size, although clearly putting a large fish in a small tank will look weird and be bad for the fish, it is fish activity level, metabolic rate, food availability, and perceived need for territory, that determines desired minimum tank size. I would suggest waiting until you have the tank size required.

[fscmocsaj]

I currently have a long nose hawkfish and im looking at these fish to get. Plus I have a zoo, mushroom and Kenya tree frag in the tank.

1)neon goby
2)sleeper blue dot goby
3)orange spotted goby
4)tiger watchman goby
5)Mandarin dragonette
6)flasher wrasse (mccosker)
7)cleaner wrasse
8)black nox angel fish
9)Harlequin bass

I'm not looking to get all these fish but your advice on how they would do with a longnose hawkfish and corals.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by fscmocsaj

I currently have a long nose hawkfish and im looking at these fish to get. Plus I have a zoo, mushroom and Kenya tree frag in the tank.

1)neon goby short lived
2)sleeper blue dot goby not desirable in this sized tank as it will deplete the tank of beneficial organisms in the sand
3)orange spotted goby either this one or the one below (but not both)
4)tiger watchman goby
5)Mandarin dragonette not desirable in this sized tank as it will starve to death in the long run
6)flasher wrasse (mccosker) needs a larger tank
7)cleaner wrasse only African collected ones will survive long term but this will not clean parasites off your fish and the fish on your list will not allow cleaning in any case
8)black nox angel fish needs a larger tank, not coral safe
9)Harlequin bass not compatible with bottom dwelling fish above

I'm not looking to get all these fish but your advice on how they would do with a longnose hawkfish and corals.

a longnose hawkfish is not a behavior problem but it does eat shrimp

[daweedski]

Hi,
I have some concerns if you guys could check out my thread http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/sh....php?t=2335331