PLEASE check out your intended fish purchases here first!

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by mpderksen

"Small" would rule out a Starry Beenie, I am guessing.
Would 2 neon goby and a Clown goby be fine?

Thank you in advance.

One neon goby is fine (two would fight), likewise a clown goby would be fine. Any algae eater would not.

[usingthejohn]

I am picking up 2 rhomboid wrasses monday and was given 2 options: a male/female pair, or 2 females. I'm thinking of going 2 females as it's nearly 200 cheaper. However with this option, will 1 of the females eventually change to a male?

Thank you, Steve.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by usingthejohn

I am picking up 2 rhomboid wrasses monday and was given 2 options: a male/female pair, or 2 females. I'm thinking of going 2 females as it's nearly 200 cheaper. However with this option, will 1 of the females eventually change to a male?

Thank you, Steve.

Yes. With two female fairy wrasses be sure they are slightly different size.

[jamayhew]

300g rubbermaid stock tank 60x60x24 (surface area of 2,827.43 inches2) with a 100g sump 48x28x24 (surface area of 1,152 inches2). I use a UV sterilizer, INS 300 Reef Dynamics protein skimmer, Live Rock, and CerMedia MarinePure Biofilter Media. This system currently houses :

Emperor Angel = 6
Blue Hippo Tang 5
Vlamingii Tang = 7
Blonde Naso Tang = 5 in
Purple Tang = 3 in
Clown Fish = 1 in
Damsel = 1 in
2 Chromis = 1 in
Neon Dotty = 1 in

[jamayhew]

300g rubbermaid stock tank 60x60x24 (surface area of 2,827.43 inches2) with a 100g sump 48x28x24 (surface area of 1,152 inches2). I use a UV sterilizer, INS 300 Reef Dynamics protein skimmer, Live Rock, and CerMedia MarinePure Biofilter Media. This system currently houses :

Emperor Angel = 6
Blue Hippo Tang 5
Vlamingii Tang = 7
Blonde Naso Tang = 5 in
Purple Tang = 3 in
Clown Fish = 1 in
Damsel = 1 in
2 Chromis = 1 in
Neon Dotty = 1 in

[MarkysGirl]

Prenoob here, I want to have a pretty tank with lots of alive stuff to watch! I am planning on a 75 gallon tank and would like to have it be BEAUTIFUL and peaceful. I for sure want some clown fish and a host anemone for them. Any suggestions on the species that would be best would be great. So far I think my favorite clown fish are the true percula? If I could have more than one pair then even better.
I love the yellow tangs but I have read that they need lots of room and if a 75 is too small then I will stay away from them.
The LFS I frequent for my FW tank has a marine tank with a blue spotted jaw fish.....we are in LOVE. We gaze into each others eyes every time I go there and I would love to have one of my very own to keep in my tank. I have read about some health issues with these guys and that they need lots of stuff to build their seemingly large underground palaces. I have not found any info about whether they get along with clowns or not.
I also think Mandarin Gobies are super trippy and like something from a SiFi film...would love to have one.
Blennies are also very cute.
Cardinal fish also seem like something from an old episode of Star Trek and I would like to keep them.
Damsels seem cute and easy. Pretty much open to suggestions for little fish that can live with corals and anemones that are pretty or unusual.
I have just started to research corals and definitely want some. I think the only thing I want to do is add them very slowly one or two at a time.
So that's it so far.....Your experienced ideas are really welcome!!!
Oh and I am planning on a sump (maybe, frankly still nervous about it flooding my house), protein skimmer, power-heads and whatever lighting I need to keep a reef thriving. I am still slowly but surely researching all of these things as I want to get the best stuff once rather than having to spend more money because I got the wrong thing.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by jamayhew

300g rubbermaid stock tank 60x60x24 (surface area of 2,827.43 inches2) with a 100g sump 48x28x24 (surface area of 1,152 inches2). I use a UV sterilizer, INS 300 Reef Dynamics protein skimmer, Live Rock, and CerMedia MarinePure Biofilter Media. This system currently houses :

Emperor Angel = 6
Blue Hippo Tang 5
Vlamingii Tang = 7
Blonde Naso Tang = 5 in
Purple Tang = 3 in
Clown Fish = 1 in
Damsel = 1 in
2 Chromis = 1 in will become one over time
Neon Dotty = 1 in very aggressive, will limit tank mates

First you have too many large fish, secondly you have too many algae grazers for the tank size.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by MarkysGirl

Prenoob here, I want to have a pretty tank with lots of alive stuff to watch! I am planning on a 75 gallon tank and would like to have it be BEAUTIFUL and peaceful. I for sure want some clown fish and a host anemone for them. Any suggestions on the species that would be best would be great. So far I think my favorite clown fish are the true percula? If I could have more than one pair then even better.

only one pair; the species is an excellent choice

I love the yellow tangs but I have read that they need lots of room and if a 75 is too small then I will stay away from them.
The LFS I frequent for my FW tank has a marine tank with a blue spotted jaw fish.....we are in LOVE.

For long term success with this fish, you will need cooler temperatures and a tank suited to their needs (sand bed)

We gaze into each others eyes every time I go there and I would love to have one of my very own to keep in my tank. I have read about some health issues with these guys and that they need lots of stuff to build their seemingly large underground palaces. I have not found any info about whether they get along with clowns or not. no problem with clowns, however
I also think Mandarin Gobies are super trippy and like something from a SiFi film...would love to have one. It is doable in a 75 gallon tank after about 9 months maturity (they subsist primarily on copepods)
Blennies are also very cute.
Cardinal fish also seem like something from an old episode of Star Trek and I would like to keep them.
Damsels seem cute and easy. but aggressive Pretty much open to suggestions for little fish that can live with corals and anemones that are pretty or unusual.
I have just started to research corals and definitely want some. I think the only thing I want to do is add them very slowly one or two at a time.
So that's it so far.....Your experienced ideas are really welcome!!!
Oh and I am planning on a sump (maybe, frankly still nervous about it flooding my house), protein skimmer, power-heads and whatever lighting I need to keep a reef thriving. I am still slowly but surely researching all of these things as I want to get the best stuff once rather than having to spend more money because I got the wrong thing.

[jamayhew]

I have seaweed offered daily to my tangs so there constantly grazing fyi

[JMorris271]

Hi Steve. Thank you for your dedication to helping out new guys here.
I have 120 gal 48x24x24 , a 40 gal sump/fuge and with 150 lbs of LR and 80 lbs of sand.
Do you think I can stock it with
2 Gramma
2 occ.clowns
1 purple fire fish
2 cranberis anthias
1 spot tailed Foxface
1 Powder Blue tang
1 flame angle
1 Diamond gobie

1 Pistol Sh
1 Fire Sh
2 Cleaners
6 Pepperments
1 Maxima clam
1 Urchin

Softies and some SPS

Thank you again.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by JMorris271

Hi Steve. Thank you for your dedication to helping out new guys here.
I have 120 gal 48x24x24 , a 40 gal sump/fuge and with 150 lbs of LR and 80 lbs of sand.
Do you think I can stock it with
2 Gramma
2 occ.clowns
1 purple fire fish
2 cranberis anthias
1 spot tailed Foxface
1 Powder Blue tang introduce last
1 flame angle
1 Diamond gobie

1 Pistol Sh
1 Fire Sh
2 Cleaners
6 Pepperments
1 Maxima clam lighting dependent but dwarf angels may pick
1 Urchin

Softies and some SPS

Thank you again.

except as annotated, should be no issues

[tonediggity]

Hey everyone, my name is Anthony and I am new here to reef central as well as a new reef tank owner. I currently have a 75 gallon planted freshwater.

We have two green spotted puffers we purchased at walmart four years ago when my wife and I started fish keeping and when we learned they were brackish fish we started acclimating them. They are now 100% acclimated to full saltwater 1.022-25

This past weekend we purchased a 36g bowfront, eshopps skimmer, fluval 50, some cheap zoo med light with one 10k and one 460nm for about $200.

I also found someone on cl who was selling sand and rock and got a five gallon bucket full of grade aaaaaaaa live sand and about 80 lb of live rock for $100! and we were happy to find a little star fish

So, take a look at the pic and let me know what you think.

My question is what light should I be using, I'd like to keep a variety of coral.

My water perams will be good as I will be buying RO water for top offs and do not plan on keeping any other livestock besides the puffers b/c they tend to pick at EVERYTHING and i'd rather not waste my money on dead fish lol.

Heres the link to the a few lights i'm thinking of getting, any suggestions would be great.

Light 1

http://www.amazon.com/Marineland-Aqu...425759&sr=1-11

Light 3

[robbie.bruce]

Hi guys, I'm new to the marine world and I'm setting up a 36 gallon bowfront.
Right now it's empty and I've just been researching on what to get.

First off I'm going to run a Marineland canister rated for 55 gallons and the heater. I'm going to get some LED's for corals and 40lbs of live sand, 15 lbs base rock and 15 life rock.

Here's my very hopeful stocklist:
Fish:
Pair of Ocellaris clowns
2 blue/green chromis
2 zebra barred dartfish
Purple dottyback
My girlfriend really wants to add a flame angel but I've seen the min tank size go from 30 to 70 and I know they can eat coral. Any way that would work?

Inverts:
Long tentacle anemone, I know clowns don't need them, I just like them and It would be a few months before I introduced it.
Brittle or chocolate chip sea star
Cleaner snails/crabs
Peppermint shrimp

Corals:
I'm not really sure what to do here, I like the polyps a lot, particularly the hairy-looking ones and then maybe some finger coral or something? Any suggestions?

Thanks so much!

[TreyK]

Originally Posted by snorvich

Quote:
Originally Posted by TreyK View Post
Haha ok, Making life easier for me is always a plus. Thank you!

SPS 60 gallon cube (24") with 20 gallon sump. OVERSIZED skimmer and heavy nutrient export via carbon dosing/zeovit/bp. Trying to decide on stocking list..

Thinking along the lines of:

1 Copperband Butterfly
2 Occellaris
1 Flame Angel
2 Bangai Cardinal tank raised, male plus female
2 McCoskers or Carpenters Flasher Wrasse [COLOR=MAGENTA"]highly active and will eat copepods so there may be issues in conjunction with a CBB; in any case a pair of flasher wrasses needs a larger tank because of their activity level. [/COLOR]
3 Resplendant Anthias a group of anthias needs a larger (125g+) tank
1 Midas Blenny may nip fins of planktivores
1 Tailspot Blenny I would not try two blennies
1 Orchid Dotty back or Royal Gramma royal gramma would be better

I realize that is a TON of fish for a 60 cube. Suggestions and eliminations appreciated. The CBB and Occellaris or the only ones I am really set on.

Thanks a bunch.
If a CBB is your primary objective, be sure to introduce it first with no other fish

Ok I have revised the list slightly.. please advise

1 CBB
2 Occellaris
2 Bangai Cardinals
1 male flasher wrasse(McCoskers or Carpenters) OR a Sixline since the male flasher's colors would be subdued without a female...
1 Midas Blenny
3 Royal Grammas

[mutiger91]

Thanks in advance for your insight.....

210g 6ft long tank. 75g sump, 3 180w full spectrum led, 120lbs of sand and 150lbs live rock. recently moved and had to store rock in brute containers for 4 weeks. Rock cycled and was moved to display tank, mini cycle complete. Mainly softies, LPS and some SPS

Current inhabitants:
Chocolate Tang
5 Green Chromis

Still at LFS:
Scopas Tang
Two bonded false percs

Want to add:
flame angel
flameback angel
fire shrimp
blue throat trigger (on the fence on this one)
flasher wrasses (suggestions?)
yellowpeel pygmy
lawnmower blenny
goby/shrimp pair
anthias

Again, thanks for the direction....much appreciated!

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by robbie.bruce

Hi guys, I'm new to the marine world and I'm setting up a 36 gallon bowfront.
Right now it's empty and I've just been researching on what to get.

First off I'm going to run a Marineland canister rated for 55 gallons and the heater. I'm going to get some LED's for corals and 40lbs of live sand, 15 lbs base rock and 15 life rock.

Here's my very hopeful stocklist:
Fish:
Pair of Ocellaris clowns
2 blue/green chromis will result in only one long term
2 zebra barred dartfish
Purple dottyback very aggressive especially in a small tank; will limit tank mates
My girlfriend really wants to add a flame angel but I've seen the min tank size go from 30 to 70 and I know they can eat coral. Any way that would work?

No, it needs a larger tank and it is not coral safe

Inverts:
Long tentacle anemone, I know clowns don't need them, I just like them and It would be a few months before I introduced it.
Brittle or chocolate chip sea star chocolate chip stars are not reef safe
Cleaner snails/crabs
Peppermint shrimp

Corals:
I'm not really sure what to do here, I like the polyps a lot, particularly the hairy-looking ones and then maybe some finger coral or something? Any suggestions?

Thanks so much!

This thread is only about marine fish compatibility; if you have other types of questions, best to start your own thread in the appropriate forum


To Reef Central

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by TreyK

Ok I have revised the list slightly.. please advise

1 CBB needs a much larger tank; difficult fish to get feeding
2 Occellaris
2 Bangai Cardinals tank raised, male plus female only
1 male flasher wrasse(McCoskers or Carpenters) OR a Sixline since the male flasher's colors would be subdued without a female... a sixline is aggressive especially in a small tank, a flasher wrasse, needs a slightly larger tank
1 Midas Blenny may nip fins of planktivores
3 Royal Grammas one would work, three needs a much larger tank

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by mutiger91

Thanks in advance for your insight.....

210g 6ft long tank. 75g sump, 3 180w full spectrum led, 120lbs of sand and 150lbs live rock. recently moved and had to store rock in brute containers for 4 weeks. Rock cycled and was moved to display tank, mini cycle complete. Mainly softies, LPS and some SPS

Current inhabitants:
Chocolate Tang
5 Green Chromis will become one over time

Still at LFS:
Scopas Tang be sure to use an acclimation box as te existing tang will not be happy
Two bonded false percs

Want to add:
flame angel
flameback angel
fire shrimp
blue throat trigger (on the fence on this one) shrimp would be at risk
flasher wrasses (suggestions?)
yellowpeel pygmy
lawnmower blenny
goby/shrimp pair
anthias

Again, thanks for the direction....much appreciated!

fine except as annotated

[izzyish]

I'm ready for my first fish, well my second fish. I currently have a blue damsel in my DT which I'll remove once my new fish is ready to come out of the QT. I have a 120 gallon 5 ft. tank. Which option should I choose for my first addition.

1st option - 3 Chromis

2nd option - 3 lyretail anthias; 2 females, 1 male.

3rd option - 1 Sailfin Tang

4th option - Flasher Wrasse

Feedback appreciated.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by izzyish

I'm ready for my first fish, well my second fish. I currently have a blue damsel in my DT which I'll remove once my new fish is ready to come out of the QT. I have a 120 gallon 5 ft. tank. Which option should I choose for my first addition.

1st option - 3 Chromis will become one over time; also highly susceptible to uronema marinum

2nd option - 3 lyretail anthias; 2 females, 1 male.

3rd option - 1 Sailfin Tang needs a much larger tank

4th option - Flasher Wrasse

Feedback appreciated.

two of your options work well but I would take out the damsel (which should not have been used to cycle the tank)

[izzyish]

Originally Posted by snorvich

two of your options work well but I would take out the damsel (which should not have been used to cycle the tank)

I didn't cycle the tank with the damsel. That's a damsel my wife had in her tank that she put in the QT because he was too aggressive towards the other fish. I put the damsel in my DT after my cycle was done. I wanted to make sure the bacteria stayed alive while my new fish was in the QT for 4-6 weeks.

The sailfin tang is rated for a 100 gallon tank under Blue Zoo Aquatics, do you think that's a typo? I'd eventually love one in my display tank.

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by izzyish

I didn't cycle the tank with the damsel. That's a damsel my wife had in her tank that she put in the QT because he was too aggressive towards the other fish. I put the damsel in my DT after my cycle was done. I wanted to make sure the bacteria stayed alive while my new fish was in the QT for 4-6 weeks.

The sailfin tang is rated for a 100 gallon tank under Blue Zoo Aquatics, do you think that's a typo? I'd eventually love one in my display tank.

No, it is not a typo, on the other hand it is a bit absurd. Remember, they sell fish, we here sell nothing; we just want you to be long term successful. I am not a fan of this vendor for a variety of reasons. Reef Central's recommended tank size for tangs can be found here.

[scags101]

I have an established 75g Lps + softies tank with a yellow tang, pacific blue yellow belly hippo tang, flame angel, a couple gobies and scooters. I wanna know if I can add a foxface to the bunch to help with algae control. The tangs are lacking in there control

[snorvich]

Originally Posted by scags101

I have an established 75g Lps + softies tank with a yellow tang, pacific blue yellow belly hippo tang, flame angel, a couple gobies and scooters. I wanna know if I can add a foxface to the bunch to help with algae control. The tangs are lacking in there control

No. You already have too many algae grazers in this sized tank. And a P. hepatus tang will need a much larger tank.

[scags101]

Ok thank you good think I have a 180g I'm the garage. Just need to drill it. And get it setup once we move here shortly. Thank you for the advice